Start with the directory linked to the exact plan. Match the clinician and office address, check any facility separately, then confirm with the insurer and practice. Keep a dated record and leave conflicting answers marked unresolved.
Start with the plan you might actually buy
Copy the full plan name, coverage year and network name from the offer. For a Marketplace plan, save the plan ID too. Open the directory from that plan’s details rather than starting from a general search for the insurer’s name. Two plans sold by the same insurer can use different networks. The CMS guide to provider networks (PDF) explains how to find the directory while comparing Marketplace plans.
Make a row for each person or place you want to keep: for example, a child’s pediatrician, a specialist and the outpatient center you visit. Repeat the lookup for each candidate plan. A match under this year’s coverage does not answer the question for a different plan next year.
Match the person, address and facility
Search by the clinician’s full name and check the address against an appointment reminder. If the directory lists the practice across town but you visit a satellite office, write down that discrepancy. If you need a new appointment, ask the practice whether it accepts new patients under this plan. Being listed and having an appointment available are different things.
For planned care at a facility, look up the facility by name and address and check the treating professional separately. Finding the hospital does not establish who else participates. Ask which other providers you can identify in advance. A network check alone does not confirm that a procedure is covered, that prior authorization has been granted or how much you will owe.
Use the same question on both calls
I’m comparing [full plan name and ID] for [year]. Is [clinician’s full name] at [street address] contracted as in network for this specific plan? I found [directory result]. Can you confirm that location and send a written response or give me a reference number?
Ask the insurer about its contract and the practice’s billing office about that exact plan and location. Record the date, which office answered and the reference number if provided. Save the dated directory entry with those notes. For planned services, ask about referrals and coverage separately. HealthCare.gov’s provider lookup guidance explains ways to check with the plan and provider.
When the directory and the office disagree
Example: The directory shows Dr. Lee at Main Street. You see Dr. Lee at Oak Street, and the receptionist says, “Yes, we take that company.” Record Main Street as the location listed and Oak Street as unconfirmed. Give the insurer the Oak Street address and the plan ID; ask the practice’s billing staff to check that same combination. Ask whether any change has a future effective date.
If the answers still conflict, ask the insurer to investigate the directory entry and provide a written determination. In your comparison, keep that appointment under “unconfirmed” rather than budgeting it as in-network care. Ask about confirmed alternatives if keeping the appointment is important. Recheck before scheduled care if time has passed. If you already received a bill, the CMS network-status action plan is a better starting point for that separate question.
Keep one comparison line per provider
Copy this line into your notes for each plan: plan and year | clinician or facility | location | directory result and date | insurer response | office response | confirmed or unresolved | next step.
Once you know which plans include the care you want to keep, compare the premiums and cost sharing in our health plan comparison guide. For Marketplace enrollment help, find local assistance through HealthCare.gov. Ask Chatter’s insurance chat can introduce a partner option; it cannot verify a provider contract or enroll you in coverage.
General U.S. insurance education, not personalized insurance, financial, medical or legal advice. We are not claiming licensed professional review. Policy terms, state rules and the issuing insurer govern coverage. Sources checked November 16, 2026.
Send a question or correction →